Aims: To assess the level of disease progression at confirmatory staging biopsies after 1 year of active surveillance (AS) and compare the detection rate of significant prostate cancers (PCas) in patients who underwent pre-biopsy biparametric magnetic resonance imaging (bpMRI) before the first set of diagnostic transrectal ultrasonography-guided biopsies (TRUS-bx) with the detection rate in patients who did not undergo pre-biopsy bpMRI. Materials and methods: Comparison of two patient groups enrolled in AS. Patients in Group A (n = 127) underwent pre-biopsy bpMRI followed by TRUS-bx ± targeted biopsies. Patients in Group B (n = 127) were enrolled in AS based on biopsy results from TRUS-bx only. Results: Overall, 6% of the patients in Group A and 20% of the patients in Group B had an upgrade in Gleason grade from insignificant to significant PCa at confirmatory staging biopsies (odds ratio [OR], 3.5; p =.002; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.6–7.9). Conclusions: Patients who underwent pre-biopsy bpMRI before the first set of diagnostic biopsies had a reduced risk of reclassification and disease progression after 1 year of AS. Thus, pre-biopsy bpMRI improves the selection of men who should be enrolled in AS.